Stephanie Mutz was on track to becoming a professor. She earned a bachelor’s degree in marine biology from the University of California, Santa Barbara, and a master’s degree in tropical marine biology from James Cook University in Aus­tralia. But while her thesis was being reviewed she took a job as a deckhand and didn’t look back.

Mutz has operated her own boat, primarily dive fishing for urchins and snails, while also trapping fish, rock crab, spiny lobster, and Santa Barbara spot prawns. She now serves as President for Commercial Fishermen of Santa Barbara, a non-profit organization that strives to create new models for collaboration by connecting fishermen with each other and with fishery scientists. CFSB is a member of the Ecotrust-backed Community Fisheries Network, which held its third annual meeting in March.

Stephanie Mutz serves as a go-between for fish harvesters and communities in Santa Barbara.

Stephanie Mutz serves as a go-between for fish harvesters and communities in Santa Barbara. Photo: Fran Collin

CFSB operates by the Golden Rule: only catch what you can sell. They partner with the Santa Barbara Fish Market, which is 200 yards from the pier and will fillet their fish for free.

While Mutz does serve as an adjunct professor of biology for Ventura Community College, her overall educational approach is grassroots. She holds a number of positions on advisory and executive boards, including serving as Co-founder for Santa Barbara’s first and only Community Supported Fishery.

Q. How is CFSB evolving?

A. Fishermen are talking together more, working through issues, and coming up with resolutions. We’re becoming more formal with bylaws and insurance policies. We’d also like to engage more in marketing. But we want to keep our focus at the community level. The largest boat size is 60 feet and we only have two of those; the average boat size is 30 feet. Inventory isn’t always consistent, depending upon the circumstances. We tell restaurants that a good way to think about us is don’t put us on the menu, put us on the chalkboard.

Q. What are the benefits of working with someone in Maine or Alaska, through the Community Fisheries Network?

A. Having a national network like the CFN provides a common ground—it’s a way to hear other people’s stories and issues and see how ours compare. If we’ve dealt with the issue here, we can provide advice to others and vice versa. The network provides strength in numbers and support for common struggles.

Q. What does your outreach to the community look like?

A. A number of CFSB fishermen talk to food clubs, at festivals, and to people who want to know more about harvesting/quirky biology about seafood. My passion has always been teaching, and I’ve realized that I prefer grassroots, organic education. I want to nerd out and tell people all the things they want to learn about.

When I first started outreaching to the community seven or so years ago, I was on my soap box, telling people what they should and shouldn’t do and I realized that I have to relate to people on their level. I’m still learning how to get my message out in language that is accessible to the public and sometimes I need to tone down my approach. I used to teach people how to fillet a fish and boil a crab on Earth Day. Some people had a visceral reaction to me killing food right there on Earth Day!

Q. Is there a good return on investment in outreach?

A. We’re seeing a lot more fishermen getting involved in direct marketing, but it is extra work. I enjoy helping people with strategy; I’d like to be a consultant for fishermen. There’s a communal nature to the industry—consumers like knowing where their food is coming from and fishermen like seeing where their food goes.

 

As the seafood industry faces a wave of new questions about the legitimacy of fish labels, the Ecotrust-backed Community Fisheries Network is buckling down and working to build back public trust by establishing rigorous accountability on sustainability standards for its 13 membership organizations nationwide.

At a recent annual meeting in Portland, Maine, a new work group set to drafting metrics to more clearly measure member performance in meeting the network’s detailed sustainability standards. The standards support three broad goals: improving or sustaining ecosystem and species health; ensuring that communities have equitable access to fishery resources and provide intergenerational opportunities; and improving the economic performance of local fisheries businesses and associated community infrastructure. The standards include an emphasis on traceability for the high-value seafood delivered by network members.

Port Orford by Scott Trimble 2

Community Fisheries Network members are pushing for new metrics for to track progress on sustainability and traceability. Photo by Scott Trimble.

“Our members have understood the problems with labels and traceability for years,” says Stephanie Webb, the business manager for the Community Fisheries Network, who is based at Ecotrust. “False labeling breaks down the trust and relationship between consumers and fishermen. Our work group is concerned with establishing clear metrics that the public can understand, and working on a framework to establish a clear chain of custody from boat to plate.”

Several member organizations sell their fish under their own labels to distinguish themselves in the marketplace and provide traceability back to fishermen. Port Clyde (Maine) Fresh Catch established the first community-supported seafood subscription service in the country and now processes and wholesales its own fish and shellfish. The Alaska Longline Fishermen’s Association sells longlined and troll-caught salmon to community-supported fish subscribers in Juneau and Sitka under the “Alaskans Own” label. In Maine, Calendar Island Lobster Company was established by lobstermen in Maine’s Casco Bay to add story and value to their product. Meanwhile, members in Port Orford, Oregon will deliver fish to subscribers under the Port Orford Sustainable Seafood label beginning this spring.

The focus on transparent labeling becomes even more important as several studies and investigations have found widespread fraud with fish labels. In the most widely publicized study, Oceana found that one-third of more than 1,200 seafood samples collected across the country were sold under false labels. Fish sold under common labels like “tuna” and “red snapper” were in fact other species from poorly managed or unhealthy fisheries. Salmon sold as “wild” were in fact farmed; Asian catfish was often sold under the label of “cod” or “grouper.”

“The Community Fisheries Network believes that its new metrics will improve traceability, provide a real foundation upon which to ‘walk the talk’ on sustainable fisheries, and help consumers understand they are supporting fishing communities that care about the ocean,” says Ed Backus, Ecotrust’s vice president for fisheries.

 

An unusual coalition of tribal leaders, private partners and government agencies is working to restore Washington’s Nisqually River from its source in the glaciers of Mount Rainier to the estuary that empties into Puget Sound. Led by the Nisqually tribe, the restoration aims to fill the river once again with abundant, magnificent wild salmon.  New documentaries in the Saving the Ocean series by filmmakers Chedd-Angier and hosted by renowned scientist Carl Safina track the progress of the Nisqually and their  top salmon advocate, Billy Frank Jr.

Watch the River of Kings episodes below.

 

Billy Frank, Jr. fishing the Nisqually River in 1973.

River of Kings, Part 1


River of Kings, Part 2

 

Across the United States, shorelines are getting squeezed.

Expanding populations, industries, and potential uses for coastal areas add up to increasing conflicts over access to waterfronts. Communities both large and small are seeking creative solutions to address evolving waterfront challenges.

The third National Working Waterfronts and Waterways Symposium — scheduled for March 25-28 in Tacoma, Washington — will address these challenges. The event will provide a forum for diverse users to address common dilemmas, and share solutions.

World population numbers are increasing, as are the challenges in accessing shorelines. This national symposium will provide a forum for diverse users to discuss solutions to some of these issues. |Photo: otEcotrust|

World population numbers are increasing, as are the challenges in accessing shorelines, which impacts the maritime, fishing, and boat building industries, among others. |Photo: Ecotrust|

Washington Sea Grant, in coordination with Oregon Sea Grant, is sponsoring the symposium, where planning professionals, elected officials, and interested citizens can learn first-hand about:

  • Economic and social impacts of and on working waterfronts
  • Successful local, regional, state, and federal strategies to address working waterfront issues
  • The future of working waterfronts, including potential impacts of changing uses and climates
  • Keeping waterfront industries commercially viable

One of the panels, moderated by Ecotrust’s VP for Fisheries Ed Backus, will focus on the way community-based fisheries are inherently intertwined with and dependent on access to working waterfronts and waterways.  Panelists will include members of the Community Fisheries Network, a group of 15 community-based fishing organizations and supporting organizations from around the United States that have joined together to address common challenges faced by small-scale fisheries.  The panel will focus on the critical role working waterfronts play in supporting community-based fisheries and how successful fishing businesses can help communities preserve their working waterfronts. By investing in their infrastructure, their businesses, their communities, their deckhands and crew, and by engaging in creative marketing, small-scale fisheries across the country can help ensure there is enough revenue crossing the wharves they rely on to ensure the long-term sustainability of their communities.

Attendees are expected to include local, regional, tribal, and national decision-makers; members of the commercial fishing, marine, and tourism industries; developers and property owners; business owners; community planners; and waterfront advocates.

Following a 2007 Maine Sea Grant report, Access to the Waterfront: Issues and Solutions Across the Nation, the first national symposium was held in 2007 in Norfolk, Virginia, followed by a second one in Portland, Maine, in 2010.

Working waterfronts provide valuable economic and environmental resources to coastal communities. |Photo: Ecotrust|

Working waterfronts provide valuable economic and environmental resources to coastal communities.
|Photo: Ecotrust|

After the Maine conference, team members secured a grant from the federal government to continue building a network. The U.S. Economic Development Administration (EDA) funded a year and a half study to identify strategies, practical methods, and finance mechanisms to address current economic challenges of coastal communities. The project was a collaborative effort among the Island Institute; the Maine, Virginia, and Florida Sea Grant College Programs; the National Sea Grant Law Center; the Urban Harbors Institute; and Coastal Enterprises, Inc.

The final results from the study will be presented at this year’s conference, which begins with a full day of field trips around the Tacoma waterfront and region.

For more information, contact Washington Sea Grant Coastal Management Specialist Nicole Faghin, conference coordinator, at wwaters2013@uw.edu or 206.685.8286 (office)

 

Today, on the eve of the Rio+20 Earth Summit, Ecotrust is joining the Global Partnership for Oceans, backed by the World Bank and joined by major seafood buyers like COSTCO, international aid bodies such as the U.S. Agency for International Development, and other civil society groups such as Conservation International and The Nature Conservancy. The partnership will invest targeted funds into sustainable seafood harvesting and aquaculture initiatives, coastal conservation efforts and ocean pollution reduction projects. The aim is to deliver crucial innovation for the 6 billion people worldwide who will live on or near the coast by 2025.

Whole Earth

The Global Partnership for Oceans will invest in sustainable seafood initiatives and coastal ecosystems. NASA via Flickr.

 

So why is a regional organization like Ecotrust – one rooted firmly in the West Coast of North America – joining this partnership?

For the last twenty years, we’ve been experimenting with new approaches to building resilient and prosperous communities, economies and ecosystems here in our bioregion. Now, it’s time to take what we’ve learned to a global scale.

The need is great. Consider that the oceans already supply 350 million jobs, and that seafood products provide primary protein for 1 billion people every day.

In order to deal with these realities and the coming surges of population growth and climate change we need to take novelty worldwide. We believe that partnerships like this one are the best way to network good regional ideas and deliver the radical change we need across the globe.

At the top of the list are these three tools and sets of expertise that we’ll bring to the global partnership:

  • Impact investing in whole ecosystems.  Ecotrust has had success pooling investments from private and foundation sources, buying forestland, managing it for whole ecosystem health, and delivering steady returns from nature’s dividends to investors and communities. On 12,000 acres in Oregon and Washington bought by Ecotrust Forests, Ecotrust Forest Management is selectively logging multiple tree species, selling credits for carbon sequestered in standing trees and other plant material, nurturing wildlife habitat in exchange for conservation payments and protecting clean water in streams and rivers, with an eye toward water markets. Timber and land management jobs created in distressed communities allow us to leverage New Markets Tax Credits as well.  We’re now exploring similar investment approaches for marine ecosystems.
  • Community-based fisheries.  One of the proven ways to maintain healthy, well-managed fish stocks for the long-term is to involve local fishermen in management and support them with stable financing methods. People who live on the ocean and depend on its resources for a livelihood have the greatest stake in its health. Community fisheries groups have thrived all around the world and we’ve brought innovative financing mechanisms to some in the Northwest through the North Pacific Fisheries Trust. We’re now connecting the experience of isolated communities in conservation, financing and fish brand marketing through the Community Fisheries Network. That sort of networking and the solutions that evolve from it have applications worldwide.
  • Decision-support tools that integrate conservation with coastal economies. Marine protected area networks in California and Australia were enshrined into law this past week, showing a trend toward marine stewardship across the world. Ecotrust’s decision-support tools allow marine planners to compile data on myriad ocean uses into one mapping tool, and weigh the impacts of protected areas and other management changes on fishermen, recreational boaters, shippers and other ocean users. In California’s marine protected area process, our decision-support tools allowed planning groups to significantly reduce the impacts of protected areas on commercial fishermen. Competing ocean uses worldwide demand this integrated, state-of-the-art approach.

The contexts of regions worldwide are different, but we face similar vulnerabilities and challenges on a crowded, warming planet.  For instance, when envisioning sea-level rise, people typically see it swamping low-lying Pacific islands like Kiribati, which is already seeking higher elevation land in Fiji to relocate its people. But new projections also show potentially devastating consequences for Pacific Northwest communities in river deltas should seas rise an expected one meter. Some communities around Vancouver, B.C.  would be forced to relocate and its airport would be threatened. So the city has something to learn from Kiribati (prounced KiriBAS).

Last fall, Kiribati president Anote Tong joined us in Portland for a convening of 50 other regional leaders from around the world. We asked the group: how can we foster resilience in the face of huge global change? Tong noted that his country had already lost a lot of its resilience. But in the quest to get it back, the country had offered up a massive marine protected area — 160,000 square miles — that he hoped would serve as a sanctuary for marine species in these turbulent times. He called it Kiribati’s gift to the world and it has since been declared a World Heritage Site.

We have nowhere near this sort of magnanimous offering to the world. But in this same spirit, we offer up our tools and experience to a new global partnership, part of the global experiment in scaling regional solutions for resilience.

Connect with us: